We've found 2 phrases for matched (0.116 seconds):

nip and tuck »    So evenly matched that the advantage shifts from one to the other, and the outcome is uncertain.

out of one's league »    In a situation in which one is mismatched with one or more others, whose accomplishments, preparedness, or other characteristics are on a significantly higher or lower level than one's own.

New:  We also know Zip Codes FYI!